
Italian For Beginners: This is a great love story, with realistic characters, believable relationships and a romantic heart that will get to everyone. Its style (using the Dogme 95) makes it look more realistic but also seductive in an everyday life kind of way. The story is simple, honest and charming, with involving pace and an uplifting ending. The acting is great by the whole cast, that just gets into character. I can't single out any of the leads. Overall, this is a really good movie that will make you feel good about love and life. I recommend it.

Brokeback Mountain: I really liked this. It's a poignant, touching romance, that uses all the conventional romantic formulas in a gay love story. The screenplay is excellent, with humane characters, beautiful, poetic dialogs and it is subtle. The acting is excellent: Heath Ledger is truly amazing, getting perfectly into character and breaking your heart with his sensibility and fears and Jake Gyllenhaal fills his character with life and is the heart of this love story (you can't avoid to love him). Michelle Williams is also perfectly intense. The direction is gorgeous: during the beginning it captures the Westerns, showing heart-stopping views and revealing close-ups. It also chronicles the characters as they get older subtly and explores all aspects of their life carefully. The cinematography is beautiful, and the score, with its traditional american sound, has depth to this. If the movie has flaws, those are the small episodes that could have been better developed. Even so, this is a beautfiul, affecting love story.

Birth: This is the perfect example of style over substance. The screenplay creates a believable leading character and an interesting exploration of grief, but it has many plot holes, a ridiculous ending and the supporting characters are sketches that lack personality. Nicole Kidman's performance is mind-blowing: her quiet withholding, soft delivery of dialog and intense scenes perfectly fit the movie. Cameron Bright is annoyingly bland and you just can't believe him (probably he was also badly directed). The direction is exquisite, with cold, detached shots in sober colors giving it it's controlled feeling. The soundtrack is hauntingly creepy. It wounds up being mostly a failure: a movie with a tour-de-force performance and good techs but with a meaningless story and nothing to say.

Monsieur Verdoux: This is a dark comedy by the usually sunny Charlie Chaplin, and it doesn't work very well. The basic idea is brilliant (a man who robs and murders widows to support his family) and it has some ironic touches that work. The dialogs have no wit and are perfectly unnecessary, because Chaplin just acts like he's in a silent movie. It gets worse as the story moves: the gags start by being mischievously funny but wound up being flat and the story starts as a dark comedy but develops into a moralistic drama. Technically, it's well-done and fluidly directed, but it's not very good.

2 Days In Paris: This is a very acute examination of relationships and cultural differences. The screenplay is totally hilarious, filled with realistic characters and situations and Woody Allen-esque dialog. It make you laugh because it takes a light-hearted look at extremely realistic situations. The differences between societies are alos fascinating and create a lot of funny moments. The direction is very good, making everything come together organically and filling each scene with little details that make it seem real-life. The acting is perfect by everyone: they are all talented and funny, embodying their characters and delivering their dialog explosively and naturally. It's a fantastic romantic comedy.


Mean Creek: This is a great, very sensitive and poetic movie about being a teenager. It perfectly captures the changes and feelings, the fear of having to choose. The characters are realistic and human, with flaws and problems, but also qualities, the dialog is incredibly natural, the story has a striking simplicity with lots of thoughts running under. The acting is amazing: some of the most natural performances you'll see delivered by a very young cast. They are all brilliant, and extremely charismatic and capture the feelings, always embodying their characters. They have a great, almost palpable chemistry between them. The direction is excellent: Jacob Aaron Estes involves you and gets the ideas and thoughts across . The cinematography is brilliant: the color is rich, while believable, and the hand-held camera is perfectly used to get you into the movie while there also are some revealing, simply beautiful still shots. The soundtrack is also amazing, giving the movie an ethereal feeling and making it even more poignant. Overall, this is a truthful, beautiful representation of teenage life.

Away From Her: This is an impressive romantic drama. It's the story of a couple, married for many years, when she discovers she suffers from Alzheimer's disease. The screenplay is beautiful, with believable, poetic dialog, realistic, well-defined characters and a simple, well-developed story told at the right pace. All it's elements work together. The acting is perfect: Julie Christie is incredibly expressive and fills her character with personality, life, youth and beauty; George Pinsent lets Julie Christie shine, while affectingly portraying Grant, an example of perfectly-suited underacting. The supporting actresses are also excellent. The direction is mature and amazingly captures the suffering and pain of this situation without ever being sappy or begging for sympathy:a rare thing. The sets, wardrobe, cinematography and score are disarmingly simple but make all the emotion flourish and are realistic and well-suited. Overall, this is a brilliant drama with great sensibility and honesty.
